@ g Ivan Prisyazhnyy on software engineering

What you have to know about Consul and how to beat the outage problem

For those of you who are opened to the experimenting, you can start launching 3 consul docker instances and playground around it.

Give your servers some configuration, i.e.:

        "leave_on_terminate": false,
        "skip_leave_on_interrupt": false,
        "bootstrap_expect": 3,
        "server": true,
        "retry_join": [ ... ],
        "rejoin_after_leave": true

Start consuls:

    $ docker run -P -v /tmp/node1:/data --name node1 -h node1 -i -t --entrypoint=/bin/bash progrium/consul
    $$ consul agent -config-file=/data/config -data-dir=/data

To the rest, you should know the following:

How Consul manages cluster membership

Consul does the cluster management in the 3 levels:

    | L3. Serf            | <-> WAN interconnectivity
    |                     |                       ^
    | - peers list        |                       |
    | WAN connected nodes |         (broadcasting)|
    |                     |                       |
    \---------------------/                       |
    /-----------------------------------\         v
    | L2. Serf                          | <-> LAN interconn
    |                                   |      | - node join
    | - peers list                      |      | - node leave
    | LAN connected servers and clients |      | - node reap
    | - node1 (srv)                     |      | - ign: update
    | - node2 (srv)                     |      | - ign: user
    | - node3 (cli)                     |      | - ign: qry
    |                                   |      |
    \-----------------------------------/      |
    /-------------------------\                v
    | L1. Raft                | <-> Quorum consensus
    |                         |     Leadeship election
    | - LAN srvs peers list   |     (leader do)
    | consistent fsm and db   |             |
    | journal / log           |        (r/w)|
    | followers streaming     |             |
    |                         |             |
    \-------------------------/             v
    | KV DB <-> Key-Value persistent storage       |
    |                                              |
    | - consistent writes, con/stale reads allowed |
    | Events ss          |
    |                    |+---> LAN/WAN broadcast
    | - lan broadcasting |

What to look at

  • Consul servers are not the same as Consul clients.
  • Serf manages membership questions like node joining / leaving.
  • Raft manages leadership questions and consistency.
  • Each level of management has its own peers list (nodes joined or leaved). The key word is - they are separate and handled separately.
  • What you want is to keep quorum in a fine state (leader is present) - thats why you should be interested in the state of the Raft peers list (which can differ from what LAN level serf currently observes).
  • The point of having Raft peers list separate is to have a list of nodes which are deciding who will be the leader in the quorum, because LAN`s list for example also contains all clients inside.
  • Raft peers list controlled by the 1) Leader (actual join / leave management) 2) LAN Serf layer events (new, failed, left nodes events).
  • Raft (L1) and Serf (L2) peers lists may be unsynced in a way of containing totally different nodes. In that case, if your raft peers list contains some old nodes ip’s which missing in the lan`s serf, then you have to go and get rid of them manually.
  • You can add or remove nodes from the quorum until it is in the consistent (leader present) state and there are at least 2 nodes present.

The whole point of the Outage page is a) you are responsible for the quorum health, b) you are responsible for the right values in the raft peers list, c) if something went wrong, fix raft peers manually at every server node and restart the whole cluster.

For quorum to be healthy it is necessary for every node to know the neighbours that are kept in the raft peers list at raft/peers.json. You should have at least 2 known nodes there (i.e. self + another one at least, and self btw may be omitted) in order for quorum to be able to elect a leader on startup.

Available node states are:

  • bootstrap is a bootstrapping mode in which you allow a single consul node to elect it self as a leader of its own single node cluster. You are not allowed to have another nodes joined / found in the cluster started in this mode. Both servers joined in this mode will found each other in the serf peers list, but not in raft - so they will not build up a quorum. Though they will keep holding self leadership each.

  • bootstrap expect is another bootstrap mode which allows multi nodes quorum. It introduces expectation number, which is the number of server nodes to wait for quorum start. No actions in this mode will be taken until all expected nodes appeared up and known.

  • Initialized means literally bootstrap happened once ago. raft/ and serf/ path should be present representing current node state. In this mode, in the case of multi nodes quorum, it can be built up from ground up having at least 2 nodes in raft peers with no respect to original expect number (if it was for example greater than you end up).

Available operational modes are:

  • Single node cluster must be explicitly enabled with a special flag (bootstrap) which restricts any other configuration (more than 1 known server) for this specific node. It can not be part of any other cluster.

  • Multi nodes cluster can be enabled by omitting the single mode flags. Thanks to Raft - leader can be elected even in the case of at least 2 nodes are present. Its fine for Consul. It can go with 2. Its not recommended though. Thus, multi nodes cluster can’t go under 2 nodes quorum. In that state it will lose leadership because single node clusters in this mode are not allowed.

    From the other side, if node came to a 1 single node state, it means you have a brain split situation in which it can’t operate further, as it will suppose the majority of the nodes is somewhere there.

What are your bootstrap and expect server values

In order to restore your cluster (raft quorum) you need to know/ be sure you have consistent set of those two (bootstrap mode, expect count) values across your set of consuls servers.

Where are your raft/peers.json, serf/local.snapshot locates and what they contain

In the situation of the outage you will want to find out in what state your cluster is. It can be done through looking across your serf and raft peers list.

  • raft/peers.json contains currently known raft peers set - literally the nodes that take part in the quorum and consensus.

  • serf/*.snapshot contains journal of serf protocol progressing through time. You can be interested in it to find out what events took place during the time.

  • ./consul members -detailed or /v1/catalog/nodes will show you current serf (lan / wan) peers list.

      $ docker exec node1 consul members -detailed
  • /v1/status/leader will give you current leader status in terms of elected node address.

      $ curl -v

Configuration of leave event on termination

There are 2 parameters that effect behaviour of cluster members on shutdown and restart. You must be interested in considering those if you willing to keep quorum in a fixed state (i.e. w/o leaving nodes mostly) or restart machines often and in parallel.

It should be decided which mode of operation is preferred: either you allow consul to auto leave quorum on shutdown, or you count on your self manually managing peers left with leave or force-leave.

If you allow consul to publish leaving event on a node shutdown and then pushes whole cluster to restart you will end up fully broken cluster with no quorum at all.

Default response to the signals

  • SIGHUP - Reload, always. Only some things can be reloaded,
  • SIGINT - Graceful leave by default, can be configured to be non-graceful,
  • SIGTERM - Non-graceful leave. Can be configured to be graceful.

What to do in the outage situation of Multi-Server Cluster

This is kind of situation in which you end up with No cluster leader and it cant heal it self. That means that you lost your quorum and the quorum lost the majority. Actually in the multi node cluster mode it will mean that your raft peers links are completely wrong (i.e. case when each node knows about it self only).

Read the Outage doc.

In order to make your cluster work again, you have to put it into the consistent state in which the leader and the quorum are present:

  1. Get rid of missing/dead peers from raft peers list,
  2. Make rest of good nodes to know about each other, so they should be contained in each others raft peers lists.
  3. Rebuild the quorum and elect the leader

To achieve this follow this steps:

  1. Detect do you have a quorum and the leader present

     $ curl -v
     $ curl -v
  2. If your consul nodes are up and joined together, you can verify they see each other checking serf peers list

     $ consul members -detailed
  3. Check raft peers list to contain right set of nodes across every consul server that should form the quorum. By right I mean:

    3.1. no dead, left, failed servers are present

    3.2. all server nodes are in there and seen by serf (check topic 2) as well.

    In order to do it, go to raft/peers.json, open, read, add and/or remove nodes, save. Repeat on every node. If you ran into this situations of unsynced raft peers across the cluster, you have to stop the nodes before manually fixing raft peers list.

    After you are sure raft/peers.json files are good, start everything up. Consul will succeed in building the quorum and electing the new leader.

    Example of what your raft peers file should look like for 3 consul servers:


    If you have only single entry there, [] or null it rather means it is wrong.

About the outage doc

It missing some points in the part of manually fixing raft/peers.json.

  1. It is not enough to just get rid of failed nodes. You have to make sure you have all other healthy nodes in there. Without it you will not build up a quorum. Without a working quorum, its impossible to:

  2. do what they claim next:

    If any servers managed to perform a graceful leave, you may need to have then rejoin the cluster using the join command`

    before doing that, you should fix your quorum (or add/restore them manually straight to the json file).

    In the case you have to fix your peers json files manually, it makes sense to add everything you need at once.

Case we ran into

  1. We have restarted the whole cluster in parallel

  2. skip_leave_on_interrupt was set to false, so every node issued leave event to the cluster, so they end up with cleared raft peers list each.

  3. After restart they of course failed to build a quorum without any neighbours in the raft list.

To fix it, we restored original raft/peers.json file on each server node and restarted the cluster.

Observable Consul behaviour on term

All Consul servers have consul service embedded. All Consul nodes have Serf Health Status health check which does not exposed by default for client node types.

  • if Server node Left - it leaves /v1/catalog/nodes list, /v1/health/service/consul and /health/node/{name},

  • if Server node Failed - it does not leave /v1/catalog/nodes list, /v1/health/service/consul and /health/node/{name} having:

      ([{"Node":"node3","CheckID":"serfHealth","Name":"Serf Health Status","Status":"critical","Notes":"","Output":"Agent not live or unreachable","ServiceID":"","ServiceName":""}]),
  • if Client node Left - it leaves /v1/catalog/nodes list, /v1/health/service/consul and /health/node/{name},

  • if Client node Failed - it does not leave /v1/catalog/nodes list, /v1/health/service/consul and /health/node/{name} having:

      [{"Node":"node4","CheckID":"serfHealth","Name":"Serf Health Status","Status":"critical","Notes":"","Output":"Agent not live or unreachable","ServiceID":"","ServiceName":""}].


  • When cluster leader is present you can join / leave nodes live - it will auto update peers json,

  • You can add new servers straight to raft peers list (you can add new servers with new ips right into json),

  • If you have unsynced raft peers set and serf and there are some nodes in raft missing in serf the only option to remove them will be to manually cut them from the raft/peers.json. force-leave works only for nodes present in serf peers list first (at least for the state of version 0.5.2).

blog comments powered by Disqus